I have my own reactions and opinions about movies I see. Often, I don't even see movies based on the reviews...or I make an effort to see them because of the reviews. Often reviews are negative, yet I am persuaded to see the movie by those negative comments. So it was with one of my favorite movies, "The Ultimate Gift." The professionals were very negative and critical. I loved the movie. I loved the principles it taught--the very thing that the critics didn't like. I loved the clever way in which those principles were incorporated into the story. I loved the way that a grandparent reached over one generation to teach the next. I loved the portrayal of grief work that was shown at the conclusion of the movie. I loved the transition from jerk to hero. In my opinion, it is one of the best movies produced. My point is, that I may not see a movie the way a professional critic would. I do look for values being taught in movies. I look for a story line that is somewhat believable, even within fantasy.
When I was young, we didn't have to look for values in movies. They were always there. Sometimes, I wonder what has happened to Hollywood. Where are the directors, the actors and actresses, the writers, the producers who want to use their talents to improve America. Why has Hollywood turned away from all that has made it and America great?
But I digress! I am here writing about "17 Miracles," not other movies nor Hollywood. I just wanted everyone to know my disclaimer. I realize there are already many differing opinions already posted on the internet. I gave my retort to “Rotten Tomatoes” in a previous entry. I was going to address some other negative reviews, but have decided not to spend time on them. They are too negative. I would only admonish all who read those negative comments to remember two things. First, it is obvious that the comments are written by those who look for controversy. They do not wish to see the positive. They are trying to stir up negativism. Often their objections have nothing to do with the subject matter and purpose of the movie. Second, I would admonish all to do your own homework. Everyone, including me, has their own biases. Each of us is influenced by so many different aspects of our life, our experience, our faith. Read and draw your own conclusions, based on your own understanding. It may be quite different from these negative reviewers, who seek to pursue argumentation and sensationalism.
As I have studied all I can find about the handcart companies (and I have studied much), I draw a much different conclusion than these critics. Their interpretations are not necessarily the final word. Perhaps, it is because I am closer to the situation. Perhaps, it is because I believe that the Lord actually wanted these people to go through this experience, much as he wanted the Israelites to go through the wilderness of the Middle East. Easy? No. Necessary? Yes. The refiner’s fire comes to each of us in our lives. We don’t become pure without it. We all will have some kind of wilderness in which we learn lessons and grow strong. Or we lose our way. That is what we are trying to learn here. What choice will we make. It is what makes us saints...or not.
Elder Kent F. Richards gave a clear view of why we all must suffer. "Opposition," he stated, "is part of Heavenly Father’s plan of happiness. We all encounter enough to bring us to an awareness of our Father’s love and of our need for the Savior’s help." (Elder Kent F. Richards, Ensign, May 2011, p. 15. ), italics added.
The real question about the handcart companies should be: “Why did the Lord want them to go through this experience?” I would hope all would understand that He could have stayed the elements. He could have protected the saints in those companies so that they would not have had the delays they encountered. The cattle could have been miraculously saved from scattering, people who became lost could have been guided so as not to cause delay-- so many events along the way could have gone differently and caused a more pleasant ending. Those preventions did not happen. Why? Everyone may answer that differently. I believe…and have believed for a very long time…that the Lord wanted these people to experience the personal miracles which saved them as a testimonial to future generations. Who can tell about the Ellsworth handcart company? Or the McArthur company? The truth is that we mortals tend to forget the ordinary, the uneventful. When something uniquely difficult or exciting, unusual or frightening happens, then we remember. As the Lord has always told his followers, Remember!
When the saints had to make a choice to stay or go on, they were given counsel to pray and make their own decision on personal revelation. There were 100 who chose to stay. Do we know their names? Their stories? What happened to them? Perhaps their descendents know, but the rest of the church knows nothing about them. We don’t even know if they eventually made it to “zion.” They are forgotten, but the members of the two handcart companies who went on are remembered.
"17 Miracles" portrays events that are part of a prophecy, made long ago by a prophet of the Old Testament, Jeremiah:
more be said, The aLord liveth, that brought up the children of Israel
out of the land of Egypt;
the land of the bnorth, and from all the clands whither he had driven
them: and I will dbring them again into their eland that I gave unto